Sports Lifestyle

Which Glove Type Best Matches A Baseball/Softball Player’s Position?

Feb 22, 2024

Think back to when you got your first baseball glove. Do you remember the stiff, shiny leather you tirelessly oiled and how you slept with a lump under your mattress for weeks as you broke your gear in? Back then, that glove was probably a run-of-the-mill little league glove, but now that you’re older — or perhaps shopping for the next generation of fielders in your family — you might want to take a more educated approach to baseball/softball glove buying to ensure you or your future All-Star has the right glove for a specific position.

Here’s everything you need to know about softball and baseball glove differences by position.

What Are the Different Types of Baseball Gloves by Position?

What Are the Different Types of Baseball Gloves by Position?

Infield Baseball Gloves

Quickness is key! Look for smaller infield gloves, ranging from 11 to 12.5 inches for adult players and 8 to 10.5 inches for youth infielders. These gloves come with shallow, more open pockets for speedy transfers.

  • Second basemen excel with lightweight 11- to 11.5-inch models, while shortstops benefit from slightly larger options (11.5 to 12 inches) for added control. Look for styles that have I-web and H-web, which provide open space for quick transfers.
  • Third basemen often opt for 12- to 12.5-inch gloves with deeper pockets for improved security.
Outfielder Glove

Covering a large amount of territory demands larger baseball gloves (12.25-13.25 inches) with deep pockets to cradle fly balls. Centerfielders often prefer 12.5- to 13.25-inch gloves, while corner outfielders can opt for slightly smaller options (12.25 to 12.75 inches). Deeper H-web and basket web styles excel at scooping up those high fly balls.

Outfielder Glove

Covering a large amount of territory demands larger baseball gloves (12.25-13.25 inches) with deep pockets to cradle fly balls. Centerfielders often prefer 12.5- to 13.25-inch gloves, while corner outfielders can opt for slightly smaller options (12.25 to 12.75 inches). Deeper H-web and basket web styles excel at scooping up those high fly balls.


First Base Gloves

First base gloves are large and bendy, ranging from 12.5 to 13.75 inches, with deeper, padded pockets. These features optimize a player’s ability to scoop throws off the ground. The glove’s large size can be difficult for smaller kids to close, so it’s not recommended that players start using these gloves before the age of 10. Opt for H-web or modified trap web styles for optimal control.


Catcher’s Mitts

With pitches flying at breakneck speeds, catchers need extra protection and padding to keep their hands from shattering. Because of this, a catcher’s mitt is normally extra stiff during its initial use and may take a while to break in.

An adult baseball player’s catcher’s mitt should range in size from 32 to 34 inches, depending on the player’s age and size. Youth players typically wear a glove that’s 29.5 to 32 inches.


Pitching Glove

Pitchers are the spearhead of a team’s defense and must have laser-sharp reflexes. Their lightweight, closed webbing means there’s no open weave in the leather. This allows pitchers to adjust their grip without tipping a batter off about the upcoming pitch. The lower weight provides added comfort without diminishing the pitcher’s ability to field a line drive or receive throws back from the catcher. Youth pitcher’s gloves (12 and under) should measure between 11.5 and 11.75 inches. Adult pitching gloves range from 11.5 to 12 inches.

What Are the Different Types of Softball Gloves by Position?

Infield Softball Gloves

Similar to baseball, softball infielders prioritize quickness. Gloves typically range from 11.5 to 12.5 inches, with shallow pockets for fast transfers. Second basemen and shortstops can rock similar sizes, while third basemen might prefer slightly larger options (12 to 12.5 inches) for tougher throws. H-web and modified trap web styles are great choices for any infield softball glove.


Outfield Softball Gloves

What’s the difference between an infield vs. outfield glove? Covering even more ground than their baseball counterparts, softball outfielders wield massive mitts (12.75 to 14 inches) with deep pockets to snag soaring softballs. Centerfielders may benefit from mitts that run on the larger end, while corner outfielders can choose slightly smaller sizes. H-webs and basket webs are great choices for their scooping ability.


First-Base Gloves

Just like in baseball, first-base softball mitts reign supreme in size (13 to 14 inches) and pocket depth. Opt for H-web or modified trap web styles for exceptional control over those powerful throws.


Softball Catcher’s Mitts

Softballs range from 11 inches in circumference and 3.5 inches in diameter to 12 inches in circumference and 3.8 inches in diameter. Youth softball catcher’s mitts should be around 32.5 inches in circumference, while older players should wear mitts between 33 and 33 inches.

What Should I Look for in a Baseball or Softball Glove? - Softball Player holding Bat

What Should I Look for in a Baseball or Softball Glove?

Your personal style, comfort level and playing position are all important things to consider when you’re shopping for a baseball or softball glove.


Your glove should fit snugly but not so tight to cause discomfort or restrict movement. Keep in mind that leather gloves will stretch over time, causing the fit to loosen a bit. Also, be sure to check your league’s rules regarding maximum size and color restrictions before you buy, as well. Additionally, remember baseball and softball gloves are not one-type-fits-all. For example, first basemen and catchers wear different types of gloves than one another, and you wouldn’t have much luck on the bases with a big catcher’s mitt in your hand.

Whether you’re running down a pop fly or throwing strikes from the mound this ball season, shop Hibbett for the industry’s best selection of baseball and softball gloves, bats, cleats and more online or at a Hibbett near you.

Before you go, catch a few more expert advice articles from the Unboxed blog, like our guide to selecting your perfect ball bat and our list of what you should keep in your baseball or softball bag all season long!

Shop the Story